by Zelda

Like our father Abraham 
who counted stars at night, who called out to his Creator 
from the furnace,
who bound his son
on the altar--
so was my grandfather.
The same perfect faith
in the midst of the flames, 
the same dewy gaze
and curling beard.
Outside, it snowed:
outside, they roared:
There is no justice,
no judge.
And in the shambles of his room,
angels sang 
of the Heavenly Jerusalem.
                        
-Translated by Marcia Falk
            
            © All rights reserved to Zelda and ACUM

 

In the first stanza of the poem, Zelda compares the events Abraham experienced throughout his life, to the events her grandfather experienced in his life. We would expect Zelda to start off by writing, "my grandfather was like Abraham the patriarch", then list the points in which her grandfather is compared to Abraham. Yet, we see that the order in which the first stanza is written, is revised, since the main sentence - "was my grandfather", comes after the listing of the compared events at the end of the stanza, as opposed to coming at the beginning of the stanza.

 

Zelda chose to switch around the order, since she wanted to create tension for the reader because it says "like Abraham", but we are not told who is like Abraham. Only at the end does she tell us who is compared to Abraham - her grandfather. By revising the order Zelda emphasizes all the great suffering her grandfather experienced in his life just like Abraham. For example, Abraham bound his son in order to sacrifice him, as did her grandfather who probably lost his son in a pogrom in Russia.

In addition, by mentioning Abraham before her grandfather, Zelda is showing respect to Abraham the forefather of our nation.

 

In the second stanza, Zelda describes her grandfather while comparing both his looks and faith to Abraham. Her grandfather's faith remains complete, despite the suffering he experienced.

"The same dewy gaze and curling beard"- dew falls at the beginning of a new day; therefore dew symbolizes youth, while the wavy beard symbolizes wisdom and old age. Through this description of her grandfather, we learn that although the tragedies he experienced in his life caused him to age quicker, the young look still remained in his eyes.

 

The third stanza describes what is happening outside. The physical cold that is outside, symbolizes the spiritual cold and emptiness that the people were feeling. The terrible reality (possibly pogroms), caused people to yell out "there is no justice no judge"- the calamity that was going on outside caused people to believe that there is no God. Contrary to their non-belief, her grandfather sits in "the shambles of his room", and continues to believe in God, in redemption and in the possibility of making the world complete ("Tikun olam"), regardless of both the people and reality's efforts to shatter his strong belief.

 Meira and Miryam

Literature Exchange
About
Yehuda Amichai
Zelda
Comparing the Poems
Modern Israeli Poetry
Sources & Links
Credits

 

 

 A video clip of Rina reading the poem



 

 

 

 

 

                                               

Literature Exchange | About | Yehuda Amichai | Zelda | Comparing the Poems | Modern Israeli Poetry | Sources & Links | Credits

International Collaboration Project
phzg@nevechana.org.il
reuw@nevechana.org.il
Date Last Modified: 04/01/2004